Interview · World
Pakistan Won Over Trump. Now It Has to Win Over Congress
On Playbook Live, Caitlin Doornbos warns that Islamabad’s gains in Washington rest on one relationship, and the new Democratic majorities are hearing other voices

Playbook Live: After the Midterms: Where Pakistan Stands in Washington · 37 min
American voters settled a foreign policy question on 3 November without quite realising it. Democrats won both chambers of Congress on a vote driven by affordability and petrol prices, and both trace back to the war with Iran that began in late February. “People actually voted on foreign policy, but they didn’t know they were doing it,” Caitlin Doornbos, founder of The Correspondent and winner of the Marie Colvin Award for Foreign Correspondence, told Playbook Live.
For Pakistan, the result lands on a position built with skill. Since 2025 Islamabad has turned a distant relationship into a working one. In April it hosted direct US–Iran talks, with Vice President JD Vance leading the American side through 21 hours of negotiation. It has carried messages between the two capitals since, and has built personal trust between Donald Trump, Field Marshal Asim Munir and Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif. Almost all of it runs through the White House. From January, the White House shares the purse with a Congress that knows far less about Pakistan and hears from people who want it seen differently.
Doornbos reported from Islamabad during the talks and returns in December. She put the risk plainly: “Pakistan should do more to reach out to Democrats.”
A War Without an Exit
The administration cannot settle on a way out. Doornbos described a White House split three ways. JD Vance’s wing wants America out of the Middle East altogether. Marco Rubio’s camp wants an American presence without an open-ended conflict. And the president sits in neither camp and “makes decisions kind of on his own”. “Nobody in the White House can seem to agree on anything,” she said. The war turns one in February.
Her prescription for the talks was blunt. Each side insists the other must leave the table with nothing, so neither leaves at all. Tehran, she argued, should let Trump claim a win, privately if it has to. “There’s a lot of pride on the table, and what’s more important is peace.”
Congress cannot end the war alone. From January it controls the committees: who chairs them, who sits on them and which hearings are held. Doornbos warned against expecting a rapid shift. The president still sets foreign policy, and Congress holds the purse strings.
The Channel Pakistan Left Open
Pakistan’s gains in Washington came from positioning. It became a mediator both sides could use and a counter-terrorism partner with results, and its leadership read Trump’s style earlier than most capitals did. The exposure lies where that effort did not reach. Doornbos said American engagement ran “through President Trump, Asim Munir and Shehbaz Sharif and the likes”. Meanwhile, Democrats were hearing a different account.
That account has been funded for years. Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf’s US chapter hired a public relations firm at $25,000 a month in 2022, paid for by supporters resident in the United States. It then signed with a Washington lobbying firm, Praia Consultants. In January 2024 a PTI-aligned Pakistani-American hired Stephen Payne’s LGS LLC to meet Congressional offices on the party’s behalf. Doornbos described the result as “very strong lobbying here in Washington DC”, with its reach concentrated among Democrats.
Raza Rumi, quoted in an Express Tribune review of the filings, judged that this lobbying shapes how Washington talks about Pakistan more than what it does. Under a Republican Congress, that distinction protected Islamabad. With Democratic chairs setting committee agendas from January, how Washington talks about Pakistan becomes the raw material for hearings.
A Senator-Elect’s Opening Remarks
The new Senate has already supplied an example. Abdul El-Sayed, the Michigan Democrat who on 3 November became the first Muslim elected to the US Senate, addressed a Pakistan Association of America gathering in Michigan on 23 August. There he said democracy requires that people can seek office without “jailing and intimidation”, a line read as a reference to Imran Khan. Days after his victory, in an interview with ABC, he named Pakistan among countries using American money to violate international law, on a list that also included Israel, Egypt and Jordan.
The sum at issue is small. Doornbos’s own reporting for The Correspondent puts US military assistance to Pakistan in fiscal 2025 at about $3 million, roughly 1.5% of all US aid to the country that year. The recipient hosted the US–Iran talks and is fighting the TTP and ISIS-K along its border with Afghanistan.
Asked on Playbook Live who shapes Washington’s view of Pakistan, Doornbos chose her words carefully. She pointed to the money moving through lobbyists, Congress and the American media, then to El-Sayed’s remarks. “You kind of have to look at, like, why are they saying that? What contact have they had with this country, or maybe the opposition group of that country? It’s all about following the money.”
A Partner Congress Has Not Met
An uninformed Congress has a concrete cost. The fourth US–Pakistan Counterterrorism Dialogue, held in Washington on 4 August, committed both governments to confront ISIS-K, al-Qaeda and the TTP, as well as the separatist BLA. Doornbos called Pakistan’s fight with the Taliban “a very serious American interest” that most Americans know little about, “and certainly not even our congressional leaders”. ISIS-K killed 13 US service members at Kabul airport in August 2021, a memory she said is “still living in the back of everyone’s minds”.
She judged the military relationship “stronger than it has been in many, many years”. It is also the part of the relationship that Congress sees least.
The Mecca Pact as a Long Game
Pakistan’s other new asset is the Mecca Joint Defence Agreement, signed with Saudi Arabia and Türkiye in August. Doornbos called it “the way of the future” and “a baby right now”. She resisted a direct comparison with NATO, noting only that NATO also began small and grew over decades.
Expansion is where the pact is exposed. Syria’s foreign minister said on 31 October that Damascus is evaluating entry, a question the Playbook examined in Syria’s Seat Will Test the Mecca Pact. Doornbos was sharper about reports, which she said surface in Iranian media every few weeks, that Tehran could join. Admitting Iran as an ally, she said, “would just ruin all of the progress that has been made” during the mediation.
A Year to Hold the Ground
Doornbos set a clear measure. If Washington and Islamabad are still talking at today’s level a year from now, the relationship has held. To get there, it has to reach “some Democrats as well, and some Republicans who aren’t Donald Trump”. Her advice was to speak to Americans as a whole, “instead of just pockets of Americans in high offices”. The Pakistanis she met, she said, were much like the people of Kansas, where she grew up.
The window is short. The new Congress sits from 3 January, and committee chairs will form their view of Pakistan from whoever briefs them first. Some of those briefings have already been given, at a community hall in Michigan.
Bottom Line
Pakistan’s standing in Washington rests on its role in the Iran talks and its counter-terrorism record, both carried almost entirely through the White House. Democrats take control of both chambers on 3 January. A senator-elect has already named Pakistan in his call to end unconditional military aid, which amounted to about $3 million in fiscal 2025. PTI-aligned lobbyists have been working Congressional offices since at least 2024.
Unresolved
- Whether El-Sayed will seek conditions on Pakistan’s aid through legislation, or confine the issue to interviews.
- Which Democrats will chair the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and the House Foreign Affairs Committee.
- Islamabad has published no plan for engaging the new majorities.
- Whether Syria will apply to join the Mecca Pact.
What To Watch
- 3 January 2027: the 120th Congress convenes.
- Committee assignments and the first foreign affairs hearings in January and February.
- Doornbos’s reporting trip to Pakistan in December.
- The first anniversary of the Iran war in late February 2027.
The Pakistan Playbook will keep reporting on how the new Congress approaches Pakistan.
Also read: What Washington Got Wrong About Pakistan, and What It Is Getting Right Now. It covers how Washington’s view of Islamabad shifted, which is the baseline this piece measures against.
Watch the full episode: After the Midterms: Where Pakistan Stands in Washington | Caitlin Doornbos | Playbook LIVE



